AI Content Review for Drupal Scores Pages Against a Site's Own Style Guide
The contributed AI Content Review module lets a Drupal site check its pages against its own style guide. Site builders write the rules, such as tone of voice or inclusive language, and set a pass mark for each. An AI agent then scores each page, explains the score and suggests fixes, and editors decide which suggestions to act on.
The scores, the explanations and the checklist of accepted suggestions all work without changing a page. Suggestions can also be written into a page with one click, through an Apply button, and that part of the alpha is still being refined. In the current release, 1.0.0-alpha3, Apply rewrites the whole text field a suggestion targets rather than only the sentence it quotes, so it is best tried on test content for now.1 In tests by The DropTimes, a content type with content moderation kept the earlier text in the previous revision.
The maintainers have already reworked Apply on both of the module's development branches, so that it changes only the quoted passage and saves each change as a new revision, and sites get it when a tagged release includes it. Their roadmap to a stable 1.0.0, set out by David Galeano of Factorial.io, one of the maintainers, goes further, with an Apply that no longer saves the page by itself and a review history with rollback.2
How a Review Works
Reviews are set up as rules. Each rule covers one entity type and the bundles chosen within it, such as basic pages or news articles, and holds one or more criteria. Each criterion checks one thing, such as tone of voice.
A criterion pairs an AI agent with written guidance, entered under Guidelines & rules. The module's README advises writing it "the way you'd brief a new teammate: what to look for, and what to flag".3 Several criteria can share one agent.
The agent returns a score from zero to 100, and the module compares it with the criterion's pass mark and optional warning level to show a pass, a warning or a fail. According to the README, the thresholds "are not sent to the AI", so changing a pass mark re-grades stored reviews without a new AI call.
Site builders can also teach the agent with scored examples, grouped by aspect, with at least two in each group. The README recommends examples across the scale: one at 90 or above, one at 30 or below, and one near the pass mark.
What Editors See
Editors with the Run AI content reviews permission get an AI Review tab on each page a rule covers. Each criterion shows its score, a severity, the agent's explanation and a numbered list of recommendations. The module also adds a summary to the top bar of each page, which pins each suggestion to the sentence it quotes, and an AI Review column to Drupal's content list.
Editors can accept or ignore each recommendation. That choice only records what the editor plans to do and, in the README's words, "never touches the reviewed content". Accepted recommendations become an improvement plan: a checklist in the sidebar of the page's edit form, which the editor works through by hand.
Recommendations that propose replacement text also carry an Apply button. Apply writes the suggestion into the field and saves the page straight away, without opening the edit form.
Using Apply in the Current Alpha
In alpha3, Apply does not look for the quoted passage in the field. It replaces the whole field, even when the passage is not on the page, and saves without creating a revision of its own.
The DropTimes tested Apply on alpha3 on 10 and 14 October 2026 and repeated the test without content moderation on 12 November. Whether the earlier text could be recovered depended on whether the content type used content moderation:4
| Content type | What Apply did | Earlier text |
|---|---|---|
| Without content moderation, set to create a new revision on every save | Replaced the whole field in the current revision and cleared its text format | Not kept: no new revision was created |
| With content moderation | Replaced the whole field in a new revision and changed its text format | Kept in the previous revision |
The difference comes from how Drupal handles saves made in code. A content type's "Create new revision" setting applies to saves through the edit form, whereas content moderation created a new revision in the tested setup.
Improvements Already in Development
Eric Homanchuk of Foster Interactive reported the whole-field problem on 18 September 2026.5 Ahmad Khader of Vardot, one of the maintainers, and Artem Dmitriiev of 1xINTERNET, the project's creator, fixed it in October on both development branches.6
With the change, Apply replaces only the quoted passage, and only when it appears exactly once in the field, leaving the rest of the field and its text format as they were. If the passage is missing or appears more than once, Apply leaves the page unchanged and marks the suggestion "Not applied". In tests by The DropTimes on the 1.x branch in October and again on 12 November 2026, every successful Apply created a new revision, even on a content type set not to create them.
With content moderation, Apply on a draft saves a new draft, while Apply on a published page saves a new published revision that goes live immediately. When a published page also has a newer draft, Apply changes the published text, not the draft.
Newer changes, added to 1.x on 9 November 2026 but not yet to the other branch, go further. Apply there refuses a suggestion that would remove a link or embedded media, or that would leave formatting such as bold text open, and a new kind of suggestion removes a quoted passage instead of replacing it.7 In tests by The DropTimes, the link and formatting refusals left the page unchanged.
Levente Besenyei of Brainsum, a Silver partner on the Drupal AI partners page, has asked for a setting that applies a replacement as soon as an editor approves it, citing a custom module built for the VisitEurope site.8 The request is clear that "approved means accepted by a human editor, not merely generated or validated by AI."
What the AI Provider Receives
What leaves the site depends on how its agent is set up. The README's example instructions send the page's title and body, but an agent's instructions can insert any field of the page. The module also passes the criterion's guidance and examples, and the page's type, bundle, title and field names. On the 1.x branch, since 9 November 2026, the module itself also sends the text of every text field the reviewing user is allowed to view.
Site owners should check what their own agent sends, and where their chosen provider processes it.
Bulk Reviews and AI Costs
A review belongs to one revision of a page. A criterion runs again when the page is saved as a new revision, when its guidance, examples or agent settings change, or when the previous review failed. The alpha has no way to force a fresh review of an unchanged revision, and changing a pass mark does not start a new run.
Every run adds a review record that is never overwritten. It stores the criterion, who started the review, which revision was reviewed, the AI provider and model, and the full result.
Reviews can also be queued in bulk, from a filterable listing, and repeated daily by cron if the site chooses. Bulk runs sit behind a restricted permission whose description warns that "one click here can spend a large amount of AI provider budget". A separate permission lets a role watch the queue without spending anything.
Who Builds It
The project was created on Drupal.org in March 2026, and its page lists 1xINTERNET, Factorial.io, Foster Interactive and Vardot as supporting organisations.9 Among them, 1xINTERNET is one of the founding partners of the Drupal AI Initiative, and Vardot and Foster Interactive are Gold and Silver partners.10
Requirements and Security Coverage
The module works with Drupal 10.5 or later in the Drupal 10 series, and with Drupal 11.2 or later. It requires the AI and AI Agents modules and an AI provider that supports tool-calling chat, and a criterion's agent needs the module's "AI Content Review Result" tool.
The latest release is 1.0.0-alpha3, published on 25 September 2026.11 The project has opted in to Drupal's security advisory coverage, but the security advisory policy excludes alpha, beta and other pre-release versions, so no release is covered yet.
Developers can add their own criterion and suggestion plugins without changing the module's code. Issues and contributions go through its issue tracker on git.drupalcode.org.
Before Trying It
- Use the scores and the checklist: they never change the page.
- Try Apply on test content first: until a tagged release includes the new Apply behaviour, use Apply on a test site or a copy of the site. The project's release history on Drupal.org shows when a release includes it.
- Turn on content moderation on the test site: with it, alpha3 kept the earlier text in the previous revision.
- Check what the agent sends: read its instructions, and check where the AI provider processes the data, before reviewing real content.
- Limit bulk reviews: give the bulk permission only to roles trusted with the AI budget.
- Calibrate with examples: add scored examples across the scale, as the README recommends.
Alpha-release caution: In 1.0.0-alpha3, Apply may replace a whole text field, and earlier text may not be recoverable from a separate revision without content moderation. Test on copies of content rather than on production pages.
Disclosure: The DropTimes was a media sponsor of DrupalCon Rotterdam 2026, where 1xINTERNET, Vardot and Factorial.io were also sponsors.12
Footnotes
- 1Drupal.org, AI Content Review 1.0.0-alpha3 release, 25 September 2026. drupal.org/project/ai_content_review/releases/1.0.0-alpha3
- 2Issue #3585877, \[Meta\] Technical Roadmap to 1.0.0, David Galeano, opened 7 October 2026. git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/work_items/358…
- 3AI Content Review README and source code at tag 1.0.0-alpha3 (ai_content_review.info.yml, ai_content_review.permissions.yml, ai_content_review.routing.yml, src/Entity/ReviewRule.php, src/Entity/ReviewRecord.php, src/Entity/Suggestion.php, src/Controller/ReviewRunController.php, src/Plugin/ReviewRecordType/InternalReviewRecordType.php, src/Plugin/Suggestion/TextReplaceSuggestion.php, src/Plugin/ReviewCriterion/AgentBasedCriterion.php, src/InputHasher.php, src/ImprovementPlan.php), git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review (read 10 October 2026; re-verified 12 November 2026). git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review
- 4Local tests by The DropTimes, 10 and 14 October and 12 November 2026: ai_content_review 1.0.0-alpha3 on Drupal 11.4.9, with and without content moderation, and, with content moderation and OpenAI gpt-4o-mini, on Drupal CMS 2.2.3; ai_content_review 1.x at commit 9a4d89b0 on Drupal 11.4.9, with and without content moderation. Re-run on 12 November 2026 on the same site: 1.0.0-alpha3 without content moderation, and 1.x at commit c9ea688f (in no tagged release) with and without it.
- 5Eric Homanchuk, Issue #3585854, Apply overwrites the whole target field with a one-sentence suggestion (data loss), opened 18 September 2026, closed 5 October 2026. git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/work_items/358…
- 6Ahmad Khader, Commit 9a4d89b0, Apply replaces only the quoted text instead of the whole field, 5 October 2026 (branch 1.x), and the same change as commit 32c692f3, Artem Dmitriiev, 15 October 2026 (branch 1.0.x). git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/commit/9a4d89b…git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/commit/32c692f…
- 7Konstantine Kirkitadze, Commit 08501d84, #3585869: Give the criterion agent each text field's stored value, 9 November 2026 (branch 1.x). git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/commit/08501d8…
- 8Levente Besenyei, Issue #3585879, Optional immediate application of approved AI suggestions, opened 9 October 2026. git.drupalcode.org/project/ai_content_review/-/work_items/358…
- 9Drupal.org, AI Content Review project page (read through the Drupal.org API, 12 November 2026). drupal.org/project/ai_content_review
- 10Drupal.org, Drupal AI partners (read 12 November 2026). new.drupal.org/ai/partners
- 11Drupal.org, AI Content Review release history (read 12 November 2026). updates.drupal.org/release-history/ai_content_review/current
- 12Drupal Association, DrupalCon Rotterdam 2026 sponsors (read 14 October 2026). events.drupal.org/rotterdam2026/our-sponsors


